Everything about The Nordwestblock totally explained
The
Nordwestblock (English: "North-West Block"), is a hypothetical cultural region, that several 20th century scholars propose as a
prehistoric culture, thought to be roughly bounded by the rivers
Werra,
Aller,
Somme and
Oise (the present-day
Netherlands,
Belgium, northern
France and western
Germany) during the Bronze and Iron Ages (3rd to 1st millennia BC, up to the gradual onset of historical sources from the
1st century).
The theory has been forwarded in 1962 by
Rolf Hachmann, an historian,
Georg Kossack, an archeologist, and
Hans Kuhn, a linguist. They continued the work of the Belgian linguist
Maurits Gysseling, who got his inspiration from the Belgian archeologist
Siegfried De Laet. Gysseling's original proposal included research that another language may have existed somewhere in between Germanic and Celtic in the region
Belgian (sic).
The term itself
Nordwestblock was coined by the German linguist, Hans Kuhn, who considered the inhabitants of this area neither Germanic nor Celtic, thus attributing to the people a distinct ethnicity or culture. According to Kuhn and his followers, the region was
Germanised from the beginning of the
Common Era, at the latest.
Language hypotheses
Concerning the language spoken by the Iron Age Nordwestblock population, Kuhn speculated on linguistic affinity to the
Venetic language, other hypotheses connect the Northwestblock with the
Raetic ("
Tyrsenian") or generic
Centum Indo-European (
Illyrian, "
Old European"). Gysseling suspected an intermediate Belgian language between Germanic and Celtic, that might have been affiliated to Italic. According to Luc van Durme, a Belgian linguist, toponymic evidence to a former Celtic presence in the Low Countries is near to utterly absent. However, most linguistic features forwarded to sustain a separate Indo-European language, including tribenames like "Belgian", could be derived from both proto-Germanic and proto-Celtic.
Linguist
Peter Schrijver speculates on the reminiscent lexical and typological features of the region, from an unknown substrate whose linguistic influences may have influenced the historical development of the (Romance and Germanic) languages of the region. He assumes the preexistence of
pre-Indo-European languages linked to the archeological
Linear Pottery culture and to a family of languages featuring complex verbs, of which the
Northwest Caucasian languages might have been the sole survivors. Although assumed to have left traces within all other Indo-European languages as well, its influence would have been especially strong on Celtic languages originating north of the Alps and on the region including Belgium and the Rhineland.
It is uncertain from what time on Germanic took a foothold in the area. The Nordwestblock region north of the Rhine is traditionally conceived as belonging to the realms of the Northern Bronze Age, with the Harpstedt Ironage generally assumed to represent the Germanic precedents west of the Jastorff culture. The general development converged with the emergence of Germanic within other previously Northern Bronze Age regions to the east, maybe also involving a certain degree of Germanic cultural diffusion. The local continuity of the Dutch areas wasn't substantially affected by pre-Roman (c.q. Celtic) immigration.. From about the 1st century AD, this region saw the development of the "Weser-Rhine" group of
West Germanic dialects which gave rise to
Old Frankish from the 4th century.
The issue still remains unresolved and so far no conclusive evidence has been forwarded to support any alternative. Mallory considers the issue a salutary reminder that some anonymous linguistic groups may have survived to the dawn of historical records, that don't fully obey the current classification.
Prehistoric composition
The archeological case for the Nordwestgroup hypothesis makes reference to a timedepth of up to 3000 BC. The following prehistoric cultures have been attributed to the region, compatible with but not necessarily proving the Nordwestblock hypothesis: the
Bell Beaker culture is thought to originate from the same geographic area, as early stages of this culture apparently derived from early
Corded Ware culture elements, with the Netherlands/
Rhineland region as probably the most widely accepted site of origin (
J. P. Mallory,
EIEC p. 53).
The
Bell Beaker cultures (2700–2100) locally developed into the Bronze Age
Barbed Wire Beakers culture (2100-1800). In the second millennium BC, the region is at the boundary between the
Atlantic and
Nordic horizons, split up in a northern and a southern region, roughly divided by the course of the
Rhine. To the north emerged the
Elp culture (1800-800), featuring an initial
tumulus phase showing a close relationship to other Northern European tumulus groups (sharing pottery of low quality: "Kümmerkeramik"), and a subsequent smooth local transformation to the
Urnfield culture (1200-800). The southern region became dominated by the
Hilversum culture (1800-800), which apparently inherited the previous Barbed Wire Beakers cultural ties with Britain.
From 800 BC onwards, the area was influenced by the
Hallstatt culture. The current view in the Netherlands hold that subsequent Iron Age innovations didn't involve substantial Celtic intrusions and featured a local development from Bronze Age culture.
In the final centuries BCE, areas formerly occupied by the Elp culture emerge as the probably Germanic Harpstedt culture west
Roman era
With the onset of historical records (
Tacitus, 1st century), the area was generally called the border region between Celtic (Gaulish) and Germanic influence.
Tribes located in the area include the
Batavians,
Belgae,
Chatti,
Hermunduri,
Cheruscii,
Sicambri,
Usipi,
Tencteri and Usipetes.
Caesar took the course of the
Rhine to be the boundary between Gauls and Germans. The
Belgae were considered Gaulish (and the
Usipi Germanic, etc.) on these grounds and not in the modern linguistic sense of the terms.
Religion and mythology
The Nordwestblock area is home to several pagan deities without any clear linguistic roots or counterparts in neighbouring Celtic and Germanic mythology (for example
Nehalennia and
Nerthus). The Lower Rhine region harboured a marked concentration of
triple goddesses (
Matres or
Matronae in Latin), that closely resemble the pre-Germanic and pre-Celtic goddess
Nehalennia According to
Dumézil, the tripartite conceptual system could be attributed to the ancient Indo-Europeans. It is possible that the goddesses
Nehalennia,
Tanfana
and the
Donar of the
Batavians, their supreme god (who was called
Hercules Magusanus by the Romans), and the Frisian god of justice
Fosite originated in this region prior to the Roman Era.
The connection with
Hercules indicates a pastoral origin of the service to
Hercules Magusanus. The service of Donar (the continental counterpart of Thor) was also linked to pastoralism. The obscure and younger Norse service of
Magni, itself a younger personification of a son of Thor, has been proposed to have derived from the worship of Magusanus. This corresponds to the proposed continental origin of the Norse service of
Forseti. The etymology of Fosite (
foarsitter?) is less clear than Forsite (
president).
However, these prehistoric Gods have unclear or mixed (proto-Celtic and proto-Germanic) roots that hardly reveal a clearly separated Nordwestblock language group, if any.
Genetics
The genetic makeup of the Nordwestblock region is typified by the occurrence of the following Y-chromosome markers:
haplogroup R1b (averaging 70%) and
haplogroup I (averaging 25%), associated respectively to the robust Eurasiatic
Cro Magnoid homo sapiens of the
Aurignacian culture, and the subsequent gracile leptodolichomorphous people of the
Gravettian culture that entered Europe from the Middle East 20,000 to 25,000 years ago. A very small Neolithic element can be concerned in occurrences of haplogroup E (Hg E3b1a, 5% or less) that originally presented a clearly Sub-Saharan Afican element An equally low occurrence is concerned in haplogroup R1a1, Investigation of the Y-chromosome reveal markedly low occurrences of the
Hg R1a1 gene, whose lineage is thought to have originated in the Eurasian Steppes north of the Black and Caspian Seas, associated with the Kurgan culture.
(External Link
). R1a1 measurements read 6.2% to Germans (a 4X drop to Czechs and Slovakians reading 26,7%) and 3.7% to Dutch.
In regards to the Nordwestblock hypothesis that a unique culture lived in the region, apart from the Germanic and Celtic people, can be concluded that
none of these genes point to genetic isolation. Both Hg R1b and Hg I are largely to fully represented by subgroups having their maxima in the
Frisia (R1b1c9, the most common subgroup of R1b), in the Netherlands and Northern Germany (Hg I1b2a, also referred to as Hg I1c), and adjacent Northern Europe (Hg I1a). This result is contradictory to genetic barrier analyses that had shown a clear gene barrier along the Vistula.
The following anthropology research has been conducted:
20th century anthropologists
Carleton S. Coon (1939) and
Bertil Lundman (1977) described the dominant local
phenotype as "Upper
Paleolithic survivors, robust
Cro-magnoids with incorporated
Brünn and
Borreby and
Falid or
Faelish-Nordid, a Cro-magnoid subtype of the
Nordic subrace, respectively. The brachycephalic Borreby subtype has been associated with early Beaker cultures and the Brünn subtype has been associated with
Linear Pottery culture.
Mediterranean and
Alpine admixtures grow stronger to the south.
Further Information
Get more info on 'Nordwestblock'.
|
External Link Exchanges
Do you know how hard it is to get a link from a large encyclopaedia? Well we're different and will prove it. To get a link from us just add the following HTML to your site on a relevant page:
<a href="http://nordwestblock.totallyexplained.com">Nordwestblock Totally Explained</a>
Then simply click through this link from your web page. Our crawlers will verify your link, extract the title of your web page and instantly add a link back to it. If you like you can remove the words Totally Explained and embed the link in article text.
As long as your link remains in place, we'll keep our link to you right here. Please play fair - our crawlers are watching. Your site must be closely related to this one's topic. Any kind of spamming, dubious practises or removing the link will result in your link from us being dropped and, potentially, your whole site being banned. |